| | | Middlebury wins the toss and defers, Hamilton will receive. |
| V | 1-10 | V30 | MID ball on MID30. |
| | | D. Miller kickoff 41 yards to the HAM29, Dylan Isenberg return 26 yards to the MID45 (Z. Faber). |
| V | 1-10 | M45 | Jordan Eck right pass complete to James Stanell for 6 yards to the MID39 (Z. Roeder;J. Onouye). |
| V | 2-4 | M39 | Jordan Eck right pass complete to Ryan Cray for 12 yards to the MID27, 1ST DOWN HAM (M. Bilodeau). |
| V | 1-10 | M27 | Jordan Eck sacked for loss of 5 yards to the MID32. |
| V | 2-15 | M32 | Jordan Eck right pass complete to Ryan Cray for 20 yards to the MID12, 1ST DOWN HAM, out-of-bounds (M. Bilodeau). |
| V | 1-10 | M12 | Jordan Eck right pass complete to Ryan Cray for 5 yards to the MID7 (M. Cawley). |
| V | 2-5 | M07 | Jordan Eck right pass complete to Ryan Cray for 3 yards to the MID4 (D. Kenerson). |
| V | 3-2 | M04 | James Stanell rush right for loss of 1 yard to the MID5 (M. Cawley). |
| V | 4-3 | M05 | James Stanell rush up middle for 4 yards to the MID1, 1ST DOWN HAM (M. Bilodeau). |
| V | 1-G | M01 | James Stanell rush up middle for 1 yard to the MID0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 10:32. |
| | | Garrett Hoy kick attempt good. |
| | | Hamilton 7, Middlebury 0 |
| V | 1-G | V30 | PENALTY MID unsportsmanlike conduct 15 yards to the HAM45. |
| | | Drive: 9 plays, 45 yards, TOP 04:28 |
| | | Garrett Hoy kickoff 55 yards to the MID0, B. Rankowitz return 21 yards to the MID21 (Dan Peters). |
| M | 1-10 | M21 | MIDDLEBURY drive start at 10:26 (1st). |
| M | 1-10 | M21 | R. Ashkar rush up middle for 6 yards to the MID27 (Dan Peters;M. De Percin). |
| M | 2-4 | M27 | R. Ashkar rush left for 2 yards to the MID29 (Dylan Isenberg). |
| M | 3-2 | M29 | M. Foote middle pass complete to M. Wassel for 22 yards to the HAM49, 1ST DOWN MID (Mike MacDonald;Austin Durham). |
| M | 1-10 | V49 | M. Foote middle pass incomplete to N. Resor. |
| M | 2-10 | V49 | M. Foote right pass complete to R. Ashkar for 12 yards to the HAM37, 1ST DOWN MID (Ted Finan). |
| M | 1-10 | V37 | R. Ashkar rush up middle for 4 yards to the HAM33 (C. Bueneman). |
| M | 2-6 | V33 | M. Foote middle pass incomplete to Z. Driscoll, dropped pass. |
| M | 3-6 | V33 | M. Foote right pass incomplete. |
| M | 4-6 | V33 | M. Foote right pass complete to Z. Driscoll for 10 yards to the HAM23, 1ST DOWN MID, out-of-bounds. |
| M | 1-10 | V23 | M. Foote middle pass complete to Z. Driscoll for 1 yard to the HAM22 (Austin Durham). |
| M | 2-9 | V22 | M. Foote middle pass complete to R. Ashkar for 16 yards to the HAM6, 1ST DOWN MID (Dan Peters;Ian Milne). |
| | | shovel pass |
| M | 1-G | V06 | R. Ashkar rush up middle for 3 yards to the HAM3 (Camron Waugh). |
| M | 2-G | V03 | M. Foote middle pass complete to Z. Driscoll for 3 yards to the HAM0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 06:00. |
| | | D. Miller kick attempt failed (fumbled). |
| | | Drive: 13 plays, 79 yards, TOP 04:26 |
| | | D. Miller kickoff 55 yards to the HAM15, John Fisher return 4 yards to the HAM19, James Stanell for 2 yards to the HAM21. |
| V | 1-10 | V21 | HAMILTON drive start at 05:53 (1st), HAM ball on HAM21. |
| V | 1-10 | V21 | Jordan Eck left pass complete to Garrett Hoy for 4 yards to the HAM25 (J. Blockowicz). |
| V | 2-6 | V25 | James Stanell rush left for 4 yards to the HAM29 (M. Cawley). |
| V | 3-2 | V29 | Jordan Eck middle pass complete to Kevin Petrick for 28 yards to the MID43, 1ST DOWN HAM (J. Blockowicz). |
| V | 1-10 | M43 | Jordan Eck rush left for 10 yards to the MID33, 1ST DOWN HAM, out-of-bounds (M. Bilodeau). |
| V | 1-10 | M33 | James Stanell rush up middle for 13 yards to the MID20, 1ST DOWN HAM (M. Crimmins;M. Bilodeau). |
| V | 1-10 | M20 | James Stanell rush right for 1 yard to the MID19 (Z. Roeder). |
| V | 2-9 | M19 | James Stanell rush up middle for 4 yards to the MID15 (Z. Roeder). |
| V | 3-5 | M15 | Jordan Eck middle pass complete to James Stanell for loss of 3 yards to the MID18 (B. Adams). |
| | | Garrett Hoy kick attempt failed. |
| | | Hamilton 7, Middlebury 6 |
| V | 1-G | V30 | MID ball on MID25. |
| M | 1-70 | M25 | Clock 00:32. |
| M | 1-70 | M25 | M. Foote right pass incomplete to R. Ashkar. |
| M | 2-70 | M25 | M. Foote right pass complete to M. Wassel for 17 yards to the MID42 (Ted Finan). |
| M | 3-53 | M42 | R. Ashkar rush left for 12 yards to the HAM46 (Dan Peters). |